This is not an experiment!

Our yearly Science Fair is quickly approaching. And with the science fair comes the demand that each child do a science experiment. They can choose to present it in the class or the fair. The only real requirement is that they must present an experiment, not a demonstration or presentation of facts. This means no volcanoes, no model of the solar system or galaxies, or anything else that doesn't "ask a question that you don't already know."

We talked about the requirements for 30 minutes in class 2 days before the proposal was due. We talked about the difference between demonstrations and experiments. I allowed kids to ask if their idea was acceptable and even tried to help them alter it a bit if it wasn't an experiment. We spent way more time on this than planned, but I wanted to be sure that everyone understood the requirements/expectations.

When the proposals were turned in, I was hoping for greatness. I was sorely disappointed. I had very few kids who really understood what they were supposed to do. I wrote comments on most of the proposals making suggestions or probing for more information. I then handed the proposals back and told them, "Some of you have not followed the instructions to create an experiment and some of you only need to answer my questions before you're on your way. Just because you are getting your proposal back, does not mean that you have to come up with a brand new idea."

What do you know?!?! I finish passing them back to look around and see William crying.
W: "I worked so hard on this."
Me: "I understand you worked hard. I also understand that you probably spent some time on this. But, you did not create an experiment. Yours is a demonstration and we talked about the expectations yesterday."
W: "I hate this project."
Me: "I understand your frustration. I need you to think about the requirements and create a new experiment. I will not accept what has been turned in."

He continues to cry very audibly. Go figure that. None of the other kids were quite this upset. I really wish he would start listening to the directions the first time so he wouldn't get so upset when I tell him he has to start over.